Bill Waters ~~ Haiku

Haiku + Tanka, Haibun, Rengay, & More

When is a haiku not a haiku? (part 2)

For many years, I’ve called all of my three-line Japanese-style micropoetry “haiku”, knowing full well that a certain proportion of it must certainly be senryu. When I began this blog, though, I decided to finally step up and start distinguishing between the two forms as an exercise in better understanding senryu and…well, because I think a writer should know what the heck he or she is actually writing.  ;- )

Senryu from the top down

In a previous post, I offered as a touchstone Michael Dylan Welch’s broad definition of senryu, which suggests distinguishing senryu from haiku mainly on the basis of tone and intent. Personally I find this useful because it explains not how to build senryu from the ground up, but how to recognize them when you see them already written. Now when I sift through my “haiku” database I can say, with a measure of confidence, “Nope, that one’s a senryu.”

Senryu from the bottom up

Poems matter; classifying them — despite this blog post — not so much. Still, when you’re sending what you think are senryu to a senryu journal for possible publication, you want to assure yourself that what you’re sending actually are senryu. And if that journal is doing a theme issue on a topic for which you have no senryu on hand, you want to be able to write some.

To Michael Dylan Welch’s definition of senryu I therefore add the following by the outstanding, long-time poet Alan Pizzarelli because it sheds light specifically on the mechanics of senryu.

Senryu is a short poetic genre which focuses on people. Men, women, husbands, wives, children and relatives. It portrays the characteristics of human beings and psychology of the human mind. Even when senryu depict living things such as animals, insects, and plant life, or when they depict inanimate objects, they are portrayed with the emphasis on their human attributes.

The senryu can make use of poetic devices such as simile, personification, and metaphor. It can also employ puns, parody and satire. Unlike haiku, senryu are not reliant on a seasonal or nature reference, but they DO occasionally use them. When they do, it is secondary to the human comedy or drama underlying the poem.

Senryu are not all strictly intended to be humorous. Many senryu express the misfortunes, the hardships and woe of humanity. (http://bit.ly/1sy2yXj)

Falling through the cracks

While the definitions articulated by Michael Dylan Welch and Alan Pizzarelli — the one, conceptual; the other, mechanical — complement each other nicely, they nevertheless do not overlap 100 percent. Nothing says they have to, of course, but they leave me with a question: how should I categorize poems that focus on people yet meet the broad criteria for haiku?

For example:

frozen puddle —

school kids lining up

to slide

Based on the poem’s tone, I can view it as a haiku. I can also view it as a senryu in that it offers insight into the psychology of being human. So what’s a poet to do?

Reading between the lines

The answer, I think, is to put aside for now the question of definitions and just enjoy the poem. Haiku and senryu are living poetic forms, and as such they have been evolving over time and across boundaries of country, culture, and language. Is it any surprise, then, that their definitions don’t necessarily agree on every single point?

I’ll keep on researching senryu to fill in the gaps of my understanding because that’s the kind of person I am. But my ultimate goal isn’t to create a comprehensive composite definition; it’s to increase my confidence in my own judgment as a writer and a reader. Ultimately I have to decide for myself what is or is not a senryu, knowing that some people will agree with me and some people won’t.

Please feel free to join the discussion! How do you define senryu?

*   *   *   *

Advertisements

Single Post Navigation

2 thoughts on “When is a haiku not a haiku? (part 2)

  1. The fog lifts – thank you Bill.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Pingback: When is a haiku not a haiku? (part 1) | Bill Waters ~~ Haiku

Leave a reply?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Dragonspire UK

- Author blog: Louise Brady. Writer. Historian. Nerd. TV addict. Gamer -

Silent Hour

Prose & Poetry by Basilike Pappa

sydney lancaster: hand & eye

visual and written work from artist sydney lancaster

Makino Studios

Haiku + Tanka, Haibun, Rengay, & More

Project words

my words and works

Frank J. Tassone

haikai poetry matters

wild ink

musings about nature, art, books and writing . . .

Michael Rehling

Home of "Haiku Mike"

THOTPURGE

Incomplete Thots...

Failed Haiku

A Journal of English Senryu

words and a whisper

my thoughts put into words

Miriam's Well: Poetry, Land Art, and Beyond

Santa Fe Literary Scene, Poetry, Land Art, New Mexico

Adjei Agyei-Baah

Brevity, moments and memories

Poetry Super Highway

Exposing as many people to as many other people's poetry as possible.

Blog - Citizen Lit

Haiku + Tanka, Haibun, Rengay, & More

Some call it red

My words are ornamental.

Nature Chronicles

of the Pacific Northwest: Interactions with the wild things--Live life outdoors!

lyncrain

“To live is the rarest thing in the world. Most people exist, that is all.”

Haiku-doodle

a haiku journal by margaret dornaus

Supernaturally Speaking

Learn about what lies beyond the natural world. Gain deeper insight into the history of magic, the origins of vampires, beliefs about angels and more. Discover the mysterious World of Sena Grey.

Liz's Logic

Take a look at the world through my eyes.

objects for thinking

visuals by Johannes S. H. Bjerg

Poetry Has Value

Haiku + Tanka, Haibun, Rengay, & More

Gnarled Oak

an online literary journal

A Poet in Time

One Poet's Writing Practice

pauldavidmena

Just another WordPress.com site

dt.haase ⌖

Haiku + Tanka, Haibun, Rengay, & More

Haiku Art Site 2012 - 2017

Ellen Grace Olinger

dogandponypoet

Haiku + Tanka, Haibun, Rengay, & More

tom clausen

poems and photos

haiku andy

Home of the 1,001 Haiku Postcards + More

Haikutec's Weblog

Japan Times award-winning poet for haiku & renga

Vivinfrance's Blog

mainly poetry, also quilts, pictures, life-writing and the occasional short story.

Crows & Daisies

Haiku + Tanka, Haibun, Rengay, & More

Coyote Mercury

words, birds and whatever else by James Brush

Red Dragonfly

haiku. poetry.

Old Pond Comics

Learn Haiku Through Cartoons

Jars of Stars

... some of the best micropoetry from Twitter, kept alive in jars...

Seven by Twenty

A Journal of Twitter Literature

wildflower poetry press

INDEPENDENT PUBLISHER OF POETRY BOOKS

Yay Words!

A celebration of language and the written word (with a little art on the side).

Alan Pizzarelli

Haiku + Tanka, Haibun, Rengay, & More

Poemblaze Blog

Poetry, poetry, poetry! Did I say poetry? (by Matt Quinn)

All Nine

Collaborating with the Muses to inspire, create, and illuminate

%d bloggers like this: