Bill Waters ~~ Haiku

Haiku + Tanka, Haibun, Rengay, Shahai, & More

We need a word for that!

Bill Waters ~~ Haiku is more than only haiku, as it says in the blog’s heading: haiku and senryu, tanka and kyoka, shahai (photo-haiga), and haibun. There’s even a bit of poetics. But are my shahai really…shahai?

For the most part, not exactly — at least not in the traditional sense. In fact, I think they may fall into a new category that has yet to be defined.

Shahai are not poem-captioned photos

As I understand it, a shahai requires the integration of three components: a photo, a haiku, and a harmonious font (an equivalent to the calligraphy component of haiga). Beyond that, there’s a crucial relational tension between the photo and the haiku.

As Michael Dylan Welch states in his blog Graceguts, “the real poetry in haiga” — and this applies to photo-haiga as well — “lies in the relationship between the image and the poem.”

If the image shows clouds in a sky, then don’t say “cloudy sky” in the poem. The context of the image already shows us that, therefore to say so causes you to miss an opportunity to say something else, offering a tangential hint that creates something larger than the sum of the haiga’s parts. The poem might name or mention some aspect of the image, but most of the poem, in general, should not do so. … Indeed, the poem should shift away, at the same time linking to and leaping away from the image it is paired with. (

So there we have it: (1) a working definition of what shahai are composed of and (2) how the elements of a shahai should be crafted to interact. But the above-going comments presuppose that the image / poem combination is constructed “from the ground up” rather than (to pursue the metaphor) a “retrofit job”.

When you yourself are the creator of the image and the poem, you’re in complete control; a little less so, perhaps, when it’s a collaborative project between a photographer and a poet. But not all things called shahai are created in either of these ways — or for the same purpose.

So what are poem-captioned photos?

There I am, reading my Facebook news feed, and…omigosh, I see an intriguing photo and it inspires me to write a haiku! In essence, the picture is a photo prompt, and I write the poem — a stand-alone haiku that more-or-less reiterates the image in words — and post it as a comment. Can I call that poem, written in relationship to that image, a shahai?

I’d better consult my shahai checklist:

  • Photo: Yes!
  • Haiku: Yes…but it’s pretty much a caption
  • “Calligraphy”: Not applicable, since the poem isn’t typed on the photo

[Yes] + [Yes But] + [N/A] simply doesn’t add up to a shahai. And considering the poem’s application as a comment on a photo, maybe it isn’t one.

Brick Wall, by Jennifer Thompson.

Photo (c) Jennifer Thompson.







flaming ochre, burnt orange — / weathered bricks / in a worn-out wall

And what are sign-generator photos?

How do sign generators such as fit into the picture? I’ve used them to integrate haiku and senryu into photographs with fonts that complement the image. Can I therefore call those creations shahai? Speaking from a gut feeling, almost certainly not. But if not, then what?

After Dinner

Calling all wordsmiths…

Image / poem combinations not of the traditional shahai variety — earnest or playful, crafted with care — exist in abundance, so let’s not shoehorn them into our current conception of shahai. I think we need a new term for these creations.

What would you call them? I’d love to hear your thoughts! In the meantime, I’ll have to keep calling my “non-shahai shahai” shahai, for lack of a better word.  ;- )

  *    *    *    *

Single Post Navigation

One thought on “We need a word for that!

  1. Gary Waters on said:

    Mind boggling to the non-poet, but interesting. I apply “I’m not an artist but I know what I like” to the technical format of writing different types of poetry. Whatever the platform, keep writing. I enjoy your work very much. Your word-pictures give me great pleasure.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


We all have the mission to save this world where we live

Foggy Days And Fairy Dust

~ because even bad days have sparkle and magic ~

Phil McAloon's paintings

Improved living through the application of oil and acrylic

Red Around the World

Your friendly guide to national parks, road trips, and all things outdoors

after pink

Haiku + Tanka, Haibun, Rengay, Shahai, & More


“To live is the rarest thing in the world. Most people exist, that is all.”

National Parks With T

A tour of Public Lands & National Parks in the USA

Anna Maris

instagram: @haikupoeten

Haiku Commentary

Digging deep into the small things

Short Story Magic Tricks

breaking down why great fiction is great


Caring About Our World Reflecting About Life

tom clausen

poems and photos

unbolt me

the literary asylum

Bending moments

This site is the cat’s pajamas

The Poetry Department . . . aka The Boynton Blog

community creativity from Whatcom County, Washington...and beyond

The Cool Women Poets

Women Poets' Critique and Performance Group

Beyond Breakers

Poetry by Dean Schabner

Maternal Mitochondria

An artistic collaboration with Miriam Sagan & Isabel Winson-Sagan

Marilyn Fleming

Poetry, Haiku, Tanka, Haibun, Sequences, Art

dylan tweney

if you're bored, you're not paying attention

the zen space

a space for zen words

The Dragonspire

Home of Author Louise Brady. Writer - Fangirl - INTP - Slytherin - Dragonlord - Fanfiction Enthusiast - TV lover - Shipper of Ships Which Never Sail - Gamer - Historian

sydney lancaster: eye & hand

art & words by sydney lancaster

Makino Studios

Haiku + Tanka, Haibun, Rengay, Shahai, & More

Frank J. Tassone

haikai poetry matters

wild ink

musings about nature, art, books and writing . . .

Michael Rehling

Home of "Haiku Mike"


Incomplete Thots...

failed haiku - a journal of English Senryu

Co Editors: Bryan Rickert and Kelly Sauvage with Founder and Contributing Editor Mike Rehling

Miriam's Well: Poetry, Land Art, and Beyond

Santa Fe Literary Scene, Poetry, Land Art, New Mexico

Nature Chronicles

of the Pacific Northwest: Interactions with the wild things--Live life outdoors!


a haiku journal by margaret dornaus

objects for thinking

visuals by Johannes S. H. Bjerg

A Poet in Time

One Poet's Writing Practice


Just another site

dt.haase ⌖

Haiku + Tanka, Haibun, Rengay, Shahai, & More

Haiku Art Site

Ellen Grace Olinger

haiku andy

Home of the 1,001 Haiku Postcards + More

Haikutec's Weblog

Japan Times award-winning poet for haiku & renga

Crows & Daisies

Haiku + Tanka, Haibun, Rengay, Shahai, & More

Red Dragonfly

haiku. poetry.

%d bloggers like this: